Eatwhatever is a two-step, breath-freshening product created four years ago by a then-26-year-old Australian expatriate named Jacqui Rosshandler. Starting with $60,000 in capital, contracting out production and working solo from her New York apartment, Ms. Rosshandler and her company, Jacquii L.L.C., managed to grab a promising but tenuous toehold in the billion-dollar breath-freshening industry.
THE CHALLENGE Running low on inventory early in 2011 and lacking the money for another production run to fulfill orders to her Web site and restock her Manhattan retail accounts, Ms. Rosshandler feared she would have to shut down her start-up. She had been rejected by bank after bank (some citing her lack of American citizenship). She had decided against asking friends for money — or her parents, who had already helped at the outset — and she had come up dry with venture capitalists. As her prospects dimmed, she started interviewing for jobs.
THE BACKGROUND Ms. Rosshandler was working at a Manhattan events and interior design company when, on New Year’s Day in 2007, she decided that like her father, a successful plastics industry entrepreneur in Australia, she would prefer to work for herself. Her idea: to improve upon a South African product called Odor-Go that she had seen in her native country but nowhere in the United States. Her product would have gel caps to be swallowed, similar to Odor-Go, but it would package them with follow-up mints to be sucked. Plus, her breath-freshening duo would be gluten-free and vegan. “I wanted to be able to take my own product,” she said, explaining that most gel caps are made using meat byproducts. She filed to trademark the name Eatwhatever.
It was her understanding that the way to vanquish bad breath caused by oniony, garlicky foods was to go to the source of the problem, the stomach. Having studied acting and law, not chemistry, Ms. Rosshandler left the product formulation to a contract manufacturer. “Parsley has been used for generations to freshen breath,” she said. “People know, just from everyday life, that freshening the mouth only — especially after consuming pungent foods — doesn’t get rid of the smell that comes from within the stomach. We found that the combination of concentrated organic peppermint and parsley oils, when dissolved in the stomach, provides this fresh feeling from within. Your breath actually smells good, from deep inside, not just superficially from the mouth.”
She hired a package designer and prominently displayed the tagline: 2 Steps to Kissable Breath. Also on the packaging was a cheeky instructional mash-up of the two operative steps (swallow and suck). She was, after all, seeking a young demographic. “I had no idea what I was doing,” said Ms. Rosshandler, laughing.
She began her sales efforts in 2008 by walking into the C.O. Bigelow flagship apothecary store in Manhattan and asking, “Who does the buying here?” She left with a sale. A month or so after Eatwhatever’s debut, a friend in public relations helped her get a mention on DailyCandy’s main page. That brought $20,000 worth of orders to her Web site in 12 hours and generated plenty of buzz. With the help of a distributor, Eatwhatever soon cracked New York retail outlets like Ricky’s, Joe Coffee and Zitomer, a specialty department store; Ms. Rosshandler even opened retail beachheads in Paris and Sydney.
But lacking contracts with mass merchants, sales volume remained low. The company’s annual revenue failed to top $40,000 in 2008, 2009 and 2010. Squeezed for cash, Ms. Rosshandler could not pay for marketing or, eventually, even for her next production run. That is when she interviewed for a job selling high-fashion hair accessories.
THE OPTIONS And then in rode her white knight. Or was he? She had networked her way to Arthur T. Shorin, an investor and former chief executive of the Topps Company, a confectionary company known for its baseball trading cards, who promised candy industry expertise and contacts and an immediate infusion of $250,000, with more to come if justified. But Mr. Shorin’s nonnegotiable terms were stark. In return, he wanted 75 percent of the enterprise. Ms. Rosshandler would retain 25 percent with the opportunity to earn back another 15 percent should certain benchmarks be met. The offer included a salaried job in Mr. Shorin’s New York company, Artuitive, an incubator for start-ups.
Friends advised Ms. Rosshandler against the deal, citing the tough terms, even if she were to rebuild her stake to 40 percent. But Mr. Shorin had impressed her in their exploratory meetings, and she asked herself this question: Isn’t 25 percent of something better than 100 percent of nothing?
WHAT OTHERS SAY Steve Schuster, founder of Schuster Products in Milwaukee, maker of Blitz mints: “Ms. Rosshandler finds herself in a precarious cash-flow position and — typical of many start-up entrepreneurs — may not completely grasp how much money she actually will need to grow her brand to a reasonable level of distribution. Arthur Shorin presents a very shrewd and unique proposition. Basically, he is her lifeline. Shorin, who made a staggering amount of money selling Topps to Michael Eisner’s private equity company, has great knowledge of the candy industry. It is imperative for Ms. Rosshandler to move forward with this proposition.”
Josh Kopelman, a partner at First Round Capital, Philadelphia: “I believe that entrepreneurs, not investors, create great companies. In my experience, if a founder doesn’t retain meaningful equity at the seed stage, it greatly reduces their motivation and creates a real misalignment between investor and entrepreneur. I’d encourage Ms. Rosshandler to keep looking for alternatives, including the possibility of raising money from her friends. If she believes the company is going to create value and be successful, then she is actually doing her friends a favor by letting them invest — assuming she is candid about the extreme level of risk and that they don’t invest money they aren’t prepared to lose. I’d encourage her to consider tweaking the branding to make it more PG-13 than R-rated, as it might reduce some investor’s unease. I know it’s hard to turn down money — especially when a company really needs it.”
Adeo Ressi, founding member of TheFunded and head of The Founder Institute, an early stage business accelerator based in Silicon Valley: “Ms. Rosshandler should definitely not take this deal. First, she loses complete control of the company, and she can be removed or wiped out of her equity at any moment without notice. Second, the deal is very unusual, so she will never be able to attract other investors again. Third, the round values the operating business under $75,000, around two times revenue. As the terms indicate, she will be an employee of Artuitive, so this deal resembles a generous employment offer rather than a viable investment. This is an angel investment opportunity, and there are the largest number of angel investors in history. The volume of investors is both good and bad. On the positive side, if Ms. Rosshandler dedicates four months and meets with a lot of angels, she will raise $500,000 with a seven-figure valuation. On the negative side, she will need to meet with over 150 angels and waste a lot of time pitching to people that will try to take advantage of her, like Arthur Shorin.”
THE RESULTS Offer your thoughts on the You’re the Boss blog at nytimes.com/boss. Next week, on the blog and on this page, we will give an update on what Jacqui Rosshandler decided to do.
Case Study: A Start-Up’s Dilemma: A Lack of Capital, or Lack of Control
This article
Case Study: A Start-Up’s Dilemma: A Lack of Capital, or Lack of Control
can be opened in url
http://newsfindout.blogspot.com/2013/01/case-study-start-ups-dilemma-lack-of.html
Case Study: A Start-Up’s Dilemma: A Lack of Capital, or Lack of Control
