A.I.G., which is suing Bank of America to recover losses it suffered on those securities, has calculated the value of the fraud claims at $7 billion.
Late on Thursday, a copy of the actual agreement came to light. It was filed by Bank of America in a California court that is hearing the matter of who owns those fraud claims — A.I.G. or the New York Fed. The agreement was also filed by the New York Fed in a related lawsuit in the Southern District of New York, where the New York Fed asked that the court keep the agreement under seal.
A reading of the document makes it clear why.
The agreement spells out the terms of a deal in which the New York Fed received $43 million from Bank of America’s Countrywide unit. The money changed hands to settle a narrow dispute involving cash flows on several mortgage securities held by an investment vehicle, known as Maiden Lane II. That vehicle was created by the New York Fed as part of the rescue of A.I.G., which had held the Countrywide securities. The previously confidential agreement released Bank of America from all litigation claims on the securities held by Maiden Lane II.
But in exchange for that $43 million, the New York Fed did something else for Bank of America. It agreed to testify on behalf of the bank in its legal battle against A.I.G. over fraud claims.
In that matter, Bank of America has argued that A.I.G. has no right to sue it for fraud because A.I.G. sold the securities to Maiden Lane II and so transferred the litigation rights to the New York Fed. A.I.G., however, maintains that the Maiden Lane agreement never specified the transfer of the right to sue for fraud and that an explicit transfer is required by New York law, which governs the agreement. The New York Fed provided Bank of America with two affidavits supporting the bank’s view of who owned the mortgage securities’ fraud claims.
Two weeks ago, it was unclear why the New York Fed gave Bank of America the affidavits. But now, its promise to testify “as needed,” shown in the formerly confidential settlement, addresses that oddity. It was a contractual obligation.
Interestingly, the New York Fed did not tell the California court that its affidavits came about because of its deal with Bank of America. The affidavits came from James M. Mahoney, a vice president at the New York Fed, and Stephanie A. Heller, its deputy general counsel.
But those affidavits differ from the position taken earlier by Thomas C. Baxter Jr., the New York Fed’s general counsel. In a letter to A.I.G. in October 2011, Mr. Baxter said that he and his colleagues “agree that A.I.G. has the right to seek damages” under securities laws for the instruments it sold to Maiden Lane II.
Michael Carlinsky, A.I.G.’s lawyer at Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, said on Friday that he found it “disturbing” that the New York Fed made a contract to “assist Bank of America in its defense of A.I.G.’s lawsuit.”
Also on Friday, I asked the New York Fed why it had included this promise of legal support for Bank of America in the settlement agreement. Jack Gutt, a spokesman, said in a statement that the New York Fed had intended to hold the litigation rights and that the declarations were true.
“The New York Fed did not agree to provide the declarations to benefit B. of A., but rather because doing so helped the New York Fed obtain the best possible settlement” for Maiden Lane II, Mr. Gutt said. “In agreeing to this provision as part of what the New York Fed believed was a favorable settlement agreement, the New York Fed was concerned exclusively with advancing the taxpayer interest.”
I also asked a Bank of America spokesman whether the bank had paid more in the settlement because of the New York Fed’s promise to testify. He declined to answer that question, saying, “Countrywide provided fair value for a complete release of claims by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, and the Fed agreed to provide testimony standing behind what it had formally represented to Countrywide regarding the assignment of claims from A.I.G.”
Fair Game: New York Fed Agreed to Testify for Bank of America
This article
Fair Game: New York Fed Agreed to Testify for Bank of America
can be opened in url
http://newsfindout.blogspot.com/2013/03/fair-game-new-york-fed-agreed-to.html
Fair Game: New York Fed Agreed to Testify for Bank of America
